You're the girl next door
I watched from my living room floor
Over algebra, and chemistry
It started on a Sunday nights
And I followed you
To Wednesdays, and Thursdays
And now you're in syndication
Chorus
And here comes my offer
Here comes my pride
You're casting your spells again
Alyson Hannigan won't you be mine?
Stay out of the headlines
And into my heart
This one time, give it a shot
You're growing older
And you're doing so well
Each character bolder
It's harder to tell
Where the screen stops and you begin
(Chorus)
I'll send you our demo
If you come to our show
I'll break all my strings for you
And smash my guitar
My character's bolder
With you in the crowd
Stand there and listen
Please hear this out
(Chorus)
Here comes my offer
Here comes my pride
You're casting your spells again
Alyson Hannigan won't you be mine?
Stay out of the headlines
And into my heart
This one time, this one time
This one time, this one time
This one time, give it a shot